|
There are so many surviving copies of these volumes
that a complete
listing
is impractical and unnecessary. This census records copies of special
interest.
The provenance of each entry is established as authoritatively as
possible,
given the sketchy and often convoluted bits of information available.
In
nearly all case, the chain of owners has gaps, especially among the
early
owners, whose names are generally known only if the owner left an
inscription. |
|
Copies annotated by Poe:
- Private collector, New York. (Poe's own copy,
heavily
annotated
in his own hand.) The list of prior owners is as follows: 1.
Edgar
Allan Poe (1809-1849); 2. Rufus Wilmot Griswold (1815-1857),
New
York editor and Poe's literary executor (presumably sent to Griswold by
Poe's aunt, Maria Clemm) (sold by Griswold's son, William
Griswold,
at Bangs and Co. in NY on Apri 23, 1895 for $69); 3. Peirce
(sold
May 5, 1903 for $50); 4. John Fletcher Hurst (1834-1903),
Madison,
New Jersey, president of Drew Theological Seminary (sold March 20, 1905
for $530); 5. Stephen H. Wakeman; 6. A. W. S.
Rosenbach; 7. Mrs. George Blumenthal, Paris; 8. H.
Bradley Martin; 9.
Stephen Lowentheil, 19th Century Shop, Baltimore; 10. Private
Collector,
New York (purchased about 1993 for $120,000)
- J. K. Lilly Library, University of Indiana
(Sarah H.
Whitman's
copy, with Poe's annotations, probably from September or October of
1848). The inscription reads:
"To Mrs. Sarah Helen Whitman from the most sincere of her friends,
Edgar
A. Poe." The list of prior owners is as follows: 1. Sarah Helen
Whitman; 2.
Miss Charlotte F. Dailey and Mrs. Henry R. Chace, Providence, RI
(inherited
from Mrs. Whitman); 3. Max Harzof, New York bookdealer
(purchased
from Miss Dailey and Mrs. Chace in 1930 for $20,000. Harzof offered the
collection about August of 1930 to Owen D. Young for $65,000, but Young
declined due to the effect of the Depression on his finances); 4.
J. K. Lilly (Shipped to Lilly on September 10, 1930 for $50,000, paid
in
four installments, making the final payment on December 1, 1930); 5.
Lilly Library (donated by Lilly in 1956)
- University of Texas (formerly from the collection of
William H.
Koester)
(Whitty, Nelson, Mabbott) (Nelson auction, Nov. 22, 1915, sold for
$32.50.)
- Alderman Library, University of Virginia (Mary
Osborn's
copy,
sent by Poe on July 15, 1848, with Poe's annotations)
Other copies:
- Bayard Taylor copy. (Current location unknown). (This
copy is signed
by Bayard Taylor.) The list of prior owners is as follows: 1. Bayard
Taylor;
2. Charles B. Foote; 3. Stephen H. Wakeman; 4. John Fleming; 5. 19th
Century
Shop; 6. Unknown owner, private collector ? (purchased about 1993 for
$7,500)
- George Lippard copy. (Currently in the Gimbel
Collection,
Philadelphia
Free Public Library.) (This copy was offered for sale by Dr. Abraham
Simon
Wolf Rosenbach in 1947 for $785 (Item 477). It contains the following
statement,
in the hand of George Lippard, on the dedication page: "Presented to me
by Poe, when we parted, and when I saw him last. G. L." Although
it is listed as a "presentation copy" in the catalogue, the book does
not
contain an inscription by Poe. Lippard was one of Poe's close friends,
living in Philadelphia. He last saw Poe in 1849, a few months prior to
Poe's death.)
|
|
|
|
|