Hugh Sisson's account of the destruction of the stone is as follows: "That tablet was finished and standing in my yard. It was to be erected in the cemetery the following week, and would have been but [for] a most extraordinary accident on the Friday or Saturday preceding. My yard adjoins the tracks of the Northern Central Railroad. A freight-train ran off the track, broke down the fence, and did more or less damage to other work; but the only irreparable damage was done to Poe's tablet. That was smashed to pieces, beyond all power of restoration" (quoted by Timothy Dimmock, reprinted in Pouder, "Poe of Baltimore," Baltimore Magazine, September 1949, p. 20).

As the stones had not yet been placed over Poe's grave, the setting for the sketch is fanciful. In no way does it indicate the location of Poe's place of burial.